Tags
6th Mass Extinction, Antarctic Ice Melt, Anthropogenic Climate Disruption (ACD), Capitalism, Ocean Acidification
By TD0S
Cross Posted from Prayforcalamity.com
—–
One of the great dangers of the life indoors, is the anesthetizing affect it has on a person. When we aren’t out in the world, we aren’t present to watch the dying. Attempting to talk about this via an electronic medium, even via the written word at all, is near futile because it requires the symbolic recreation of the tragedy unfolding around us, and the recreation will never carry the weight or the pain of the real thing.
So it comes down to data points. In essays past and in daily editorials available across the electronic press, we are fed the data points. Topsoil loss, species die off, the toxicity of the oceans, the acceleration of climate change; I can rattle off the data, but who cares? We are inside. Climate controlled. Masters of hundreds of energy slaves all whipped up to provide us with on demand entertainment, comfort, and snack food. We think we are safe inside our house, but the house is an illusion. There is no indoor, outdoor dichotomy. There is a temporary delusion blinding us to the reality of the storm bearing down.
In my previous essay I wrote that we must burn down the collective house that is civilization. We must demolish it thoroughly before the floors buckle and the roof caves in, despite the very real dependence we have developed upon this edifice. A conundrum indeed, but this conundrum is itself the question of our time, and it calls to all of us whether we are ready to square off with its implications or not.
Industrial civilization is destroying the living skin of the planet. Industrial civilization is rendering life on Earth impossible. This is inarguable. The only question then, is what to do. Where do our responsibilities lie, and how can we meet them with dignity, grace, and courage?
—
What do you value? What do you value the most in this world as you experience it? I think it is imperative that we start with this question because the answer will determine how we perceive our responsibilities as living beings. I refer to this as finding one’s polestar; their true north. Finding our pole star is essential because it is very easy to get entangled in the complexity of our culture, our socialization, our class status, and all of the other baggage we carry from lifetime after lifetime of trauma inflicted by the dominant culture. When we need reorientation, we come about to our true north, and keep from running wayward into the noise and distraction intentionally laid to ensnare the passionate.
My pole star is the healthy, fecund forest. I live in a wooded region, and when I look out my front door I see tree covered ravines. Beech, hickory, oak, maple, all stand stoically about me, their leaves blanketing and feeding the soil. I never feel so honest, so at home, so centered as when I stand in the deep blue dark of night, jacketed in the electric stillness of winter, staring up to the stars that peak through the tangled black fingers of the naked tree boughs. In those moments I feel whole, because I feel like part of a whole. My ancestors call to me from the past as they most certainly stood in the same pose of supplication, lost in wonder, and gratitude, and mystery.
This is where I go when I seek an ethical thread to follow through the spiritual and psychological quagmire of modern industrial civilization. When I look at the activities of humans, I ask what they mean for the forests. Not just my forest home, but for the forest homes of people and beings across the Earth. I ask if new technologies, or policies, or commercial activities will benefit these havens of life and solitude, or if they threaten them. I imagine the creeks and rivers that run through this region like blood in my veins, and usually the answer comes back to me that, no, the grand schemes of civilized man offer nothing good. They seek only to take, never to give back. They promise to dominate and ruin, and that is what they do.
When concrete is laid over what was once a field so that suburbanites can park their vehicles at a new strip of retail stores, the deep roots of plants do not surrender. Look to any patch of asphalt and you will find the rebellion under way. Grass, dock, wild onion, dandelion; they slowly crack and push through the rubble and road surface above them until they find their place in the sunlight once again. When under attack, these plants merely do what they must do to go about the business of living.
What fascinates me is that when hundreds or thousands of enraged people burn down the corporate chain stores that encircle them like army wagons on the frontier, these rioters are condemned. Spokespeople for the status quo feign innocent stupidity and ask, “Why are they burning down their own communities?” as if the concrete that is laid over the poor and working class is somehow their kin. Setting police cruisers and corporate chain stores alight is merely what these people must do to go about the business of living, whether this is consciously perceived or not.
The hierarchy of power that exists in this social paradigm attempts to mystify the public with language of togetherness when it suits them. They speak down to the lower orders as if we are one unit, one family, one tribe, each of us working together for the equal betterment of all. The actions of the powerful betray the truth, that those lower on the social hierarchy will labor, toil, suffer, and die for the comfort, power, and privilege of those at the top.
This is the framework by which responsibility is discussed within our society. If a man robs a store and is sent to prison for it, it is said that he is there to “pay his debt to society.” There are several implications in this statement surrounding the notion that this man was ever part of society to begin with, or that he desires to remain so. Of course, if he was robbing a store to pay his rent, keep the heat on, or feed his family, there will never be statements from the powerful to the effect that society failed this man, this valuable member of our collective, and forced him through circumstance to his act. Society will never pay its debt to this man, or to any man of his social rank. The idea that we are all daily electing to be in one cooperative social structure together is a pure fabrication.
As so often happens, officers of the state apparatus commit egregious violence, whether as police or soldiers, and their personal responsibility is almost never called into question. The only time an individual police officer or soldier is made to fall on their sword, is when their crime is so blatant, so heinous, and so public, that to not punish them would crack the façade of the entire control apparatus. By and large, these officers of the state do violence as a mode of day to day operations, all for the acquisition and maintenance of wealth and power as it exists and is distributed.
However, any actions deemed antagonistic to the structure of power and wealth will be vociferously condemned, and the perpetrators will be held liable for all knock on effects of these actions. For instance, if in an attempt to preserve the health and sanctity of one’s home, a person destroys the power sub station that operates the pumps for a tar sand pipeline that runs under their land, and this outage causes a cascade black out to follow suit, the state will likely hold responsible this person for any deaths or injuries that occur due to the lack of electricity that has resulted. If an old woman on a hospital respirator dies, the person who knocked out the sub station will likely be charged with manslaughter, if not murder. They will be called a terrorist. Anyone whose ideologies are even remotely similar to this person’s will also be labeled a terrorist, worthy of suspicion.
In short, this is the Law. People speak of the Law in moralistic terms, as if the volumes of clumsy codes and commands cobbled together by and for the wealthy were gifted to us by a choir of angels designed on building for us a just and balanced world. Of course, the Law is nothing of the sort. The Law has nothing to do with morals or ethics, as the bulk of the weight of the laws as they exist purpose to extort and exploit the poor for the powerful. Leaning on the law as an ethical or moral litmus is such a high form of laziness and ignorance as to be shameful.
This is the wall that encircles those of us who wish to see an end to the current order of power. We will be held to the highest account for the slightest ill that comes from any of our deeds, and the Law will be invoked in punishing even the most tepid of social activists. Meanwhile, an Airforce technician in a bunker will kill families thousands of miles away with hellfire missiles, and we will never know this person’s name. They will never be condemned for the deaths they directly and intentionally cause. In fact, they will be heralded and rewarded. Their efforts furthered the efforts of the machine of industrial civilization. They are on the team. Doctors designed torture programs for the CIA. Scientists design weaponized viruses. Capitalists pour heavy metals into rivers and continue cutting boreal forest to extract tar sand despite the globally acknowledged threat of climate catastrophe.
These people are all protected. Even attempting to slow them down in their work is a crime. The truth laid bare is that they have a sanctioned right to bring death, and you have no right to try to prevent them, whether violently or not.
It’s not about who you kill, it’s about who you kill for.
The police are on standby in any event, ready to gleefully dole out violence to even the most passive demonstrator. Any flinch, parry, or brush of a hand that can be deemed an attack on the police, of course, will result in charges, possibly felonies. The guardians of power too, are a protected class, so much so that in some places even passively ignoring police is classed as a felony.
The message is clear. This world doesn’t belong to us, but to them. We are a society in name only. Language about unity and country are pap for the masses. Those who don’t swallow it down get the club, or the bullet. But don’t worry, the comments section is still open. Feel free to air your frustrations beneath the article. Hashtag, give-up-already.
—
In the cold night air my breath is visible. Darkness comes early as we approach the solstice. When I scan over the ridge, I feel a peace in the center of my being. There are those who think this is all that is left. They say that we have already lost the big fights, and now all that remains is to hold close to those you love as the dying picks up speed, and the maniacs in power continue throttling forward.
I cannot help but feel that such placid thoughts, wherever they may be rooted, are an appeasement to the powerful. My blog wouldn’t be named “Pray for Calamity” if I didn’t believe that things would get worse before they got better. But I also know that without question I would die for my family and for our home, and thinking this opens me to the idea that there are so many great places and causes to die for on this planet at this time. Perhaps its time to stop seeing this as an age of impending calamity, but instead to see it as an age of opportunity to banish our fears, cage our egos, and to remember that death comes for us all, and that the greatest shame would be to waste our flesh when there are so many perfect targets for our rage. Perhaps we should begin to recognize this as an age of awakening; a time to reignite an internal fire that an oppressive and abusive culture has devoted so much energy to snuffing out.
So I ask, what is your pole star? What is your true north? What do you know in the center of your being to be good, and right, and true? The dominant culture attempts to bend the mind and break the heart, until all that is left is the fetishization of power. Domesticated, isolated, institutionalized, traumatized people begin to believe that their responsibilities are to the dominant system of buying, selling, killing, producing, and ever increasing efficiency at all of them.
I submit that these are not my responsibilities, and they are not yours. I submit that none of the language they weaponize and fire so readily at dissenting voices is applicable. We are not malcontents, radicals, insurgents, or terrorists. We are dandelions who do not wish to bend to the will of the concrete poured over us.
And when we are ready to remember all of this, we are warriors.
Do you want a broken arm, or a broken leg? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AE6Kdo1AQmY
LikeLike
To find True North https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VePZv6ZCb_Q&list=UUzO9J4GouihEHngcGPhyvDg
LikeLike
a personal reblogging in german…and a short trip description of how roadkills and fouling fields from the fresh winter plough are smelling in hungary – austria, when the winter has a break and you get 15 Celcius plus in the shadow so the decomposting and rotting is emmiting these fouling gases(methane etc) from the fields and the corpses of the dead animals http://goo.gl/ecM0Cd
LikeLike
For those who have no time to read his book, listen to this:
The Myth of “Green Energy”
http://postcarbon.podomatic.com/entry/2013-08-15T12_25_00-07_00
LikeLike
“These people are all protected.” Yes they are and no more so than by the billions of consumers who will not/can’t stop or dramatically cut their consumption. I understand just the Internet takes upwards of 15% of global electricity consumption. Add in the energy and waste to produce the devices (including TV’s) and the price of our entertainment is truly staggering. We would have to go to war with ourselves. There never was or ever will be a protest where they chant “We Want Less”. For example, although completely justified, the occupy movement is about redistribution and fairness, not shutting down industrial civilization. What people really want is for someone to fix things, so they can carry on. Many can handle the thought of a less consumptive lifestyle, but no electricity, no cars, no TV, no Internet – NO WAY!
LikeLike
From Paul Chefurka (via America2.0 on 3-24-2014):
“One of the fundamental determinants and signals of human status is the degree of direct or indirect control of exosomatic energy. People who climb the status ladder do so by expanding their control over energy, resources and the labour of others. The search for higher status tends to entail the control of more of the human energy and material flows. Combine that with an expanding population, and the constant expansion of consumption makes sense. It’s also why it’s impossible to get humans to reduce our consumption voluntarily and collectively. The status association makes defections from any power-down scheme inevitable, to such an extent that they are political non-starters.”
LikeLike
“Civilisation” is inherently expansionistic. Just like cancer.
LikeLike
“…In The ‘Coal Question’ of 1865, William Stanley Jevons examined the trend of future coal consumption and argued against contemporary predictions about the possible reduction in the future coal consumption triggered by technological progress. He explained an intrinsic human addiction to the comfort offered by exosomatic instruments (the concept introduced by Georgescu-Roegen based on Lotka’s idea): increase in efficiency in using a resource leads to increased use of that resource rather than to a reduction in its use. This has been proposed as Jevons’ paradox by Jevons – a scholar with the same name (Jevons, 1990).
‘Jevons’ paradox’ has proven to be true not only regarding demand for coal and other fossil energy resources. Doubling the efficiency of food production per hectare over the last 50 years (due to the Green Revolution) did not solve the problem of hunger. The increase in efficiency increased production and worsened hunger because of the resulting increase in population (Giampietro, 1994). In the same way, building new roads did not solve the traffic problem because increasing use of personal vehicles was encouraged (Newman, 1991). More energy efficient automobiles resulted from rising oil prices, but Americans increased leisure driving (Cherfas, 1991). The number of miles driven increased and car performance improved. Now, Americans are driving bigger and more sophisticated vehicles such as mini-vans, pick-up trucks and four-wheel drive vehicles. Similarly, technological improvement in efficiency led to bigger refrigerators (Khazzoom, 1987)…” – Link
ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS 27 (1998) 115-117,
by Kozo Mayumi, MarioGiampietro, John M. Goudy
LikeLike
“We’ve been so busy keepin’ up with the Jones
Four car garage and we’re still building on
Maybe it’s time we got back to the basics of love”
LikeLike
“There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to one who is striking at the root, and it may be that he who bestows the largest amount of time and money on the needy is doing the most by his mode of life to produce that misery which he strives in vain to relieve.”
Henry David Thoreau
LikeLike
What will happen to the Internet and many aspects of modern life if the hackers continue to evolve?
LikeLike
We’re told that a major cyber attack is inevitable at any time…
Eugene Kaspersky: major cyberterrorist attack is only matter of time
Nations must be ready for a remote attack on critical infrastructure, including power and transport systems, says security expert
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/may/01/eugene-kaspersky-major-cyberterrorist-attack-uk
LikeLike
Climate: Study eyes seafloor methane releases
“If the temperature of the oceans increases by two degrees as suggested by some reports, it will accelerate the thawing to the extreme. A warming climate could lead to an explosive gas release from the shallow areas,” he said.
LikeLike
Comments are rather humorous:
http://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/2q2beh/in_case_you_think_people_are_concerned_about_the/
in case you think people are concerned about the environment and resource availability, check out Gallop
LikeLike
Lol. Some very perceptive commenter’s. UncleKerosene in particular sounds like a well seasoned Doomer.
LikeLike
…capable of drawing decades’ worth of hoarded heat out of the Pacific Ocean & belching it back into the atmosphere.
http://www.climatecentral.org/news/corals-secrets-of-warming-18468
LikeLike
The Crowdsourcing Scam
Why do you deceive yourself?
http://www.thebaffler.com/salvos/crowdsourcing-scam
LikeLike
This is a great site exposing the charlatans and kooks of the internet and around the world:
LikeLike
Thanx for ur help apneanman. included your ozzie link in my post.
http://www.reddit.com/r/Renewables/
THERE IS NO GREEN ENERGY.
by BeezleyBillyBub
LikeLike
Hey you got a friend at r/renewables, but not so much at r/collapse 😉
LikeLike
thought i drank too much when i went guy’s site
check severeanxiety767 comments
all the best this year one n all
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/professors_plead_with_greens_to_accept_nuclear_power_20141226
LikeLike
“There seems to be no shortage of rich Americans afraid of the future.”
comments on reddit:
http://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/2q5q6e/there_seems_to_be_no_shortage_of_rich_americans/
LikeLike
LOL
Me and my wife have been watching Doomsday Preppers. It’s fucking hilarious.
This guy was featured in one episode, but he hadn’t sold out at that point.
Each person is very opinionated about what the cause of collapse will be.
But, each person has devised and developed some good survival tips.
LikeLike
Life is a safe cracker, always trying new genetic combinations to get to the treasure trove within. Technological evolution does the same. Any concentration of energy/resources that can be metabolized is in danger. The insect is in danger as is the fish in the sea, also the equity in your house, your pension……none of it is safe, evolution will create some nasty cellular, corporate, or government organization to access and digest whatever can be discovered and engaged. It has even created the average person capable of rape, pillage and plunder when conditions are right. Although I am not a religious person, the combination opening the doors to technological evolution must have been 666 and it seems apparent that I am correct as we approach the satanic holidays in which the Maximum Power Principle reigns supreme as everyone competes to drink most freely from the dopamine cup. What an unfortunate turn of events and there’s no easy way back, everyone’s wired to want more wealth and reproduction in an eternal competition played out on time’s arrow. There won’t be any longstanding technological ecosystem as has occurred with organic cellular beings, the technological system will destroy itself, a power hungry cancer, out of control, consuming everything and converting it into tumorous self. Don’t you adore the billionaires of today, scions, paragons of power, temporary cancer maestros winning the international game of ultimate destruction, an egotistical delight. They are not reformable, it is not reformable, it must run until it dies.
LikeLike
“Although I am not a religious person, the combination opening the doors to technological evolution must have been 666 and it seems apparent that I am correct as we approach the satanic holidays in which the Maximum Power Principle reigns supreme as everyone competes to drink most freely from the dopamine cup.”
I laughed so hard that I had tears; a rare occurrence these past few year. Thanks James.
LikeLike
You’re welcome and Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays and so forth. Just glad I can torment and titillate in equal measure.
LikeLike
“So, the question is: Do we–meaning the human species as a whole–have any choice in the matter? Or are we as a species destined to live by the Maximum Power Principle to its seemingly inevitable and calamitous conclusion–a story in which the drive for maximum energy gain is no longer adaptive, but rather dangerous to the continued existence of humankind?
Our actions will be our answer.”
http://resourceinsights.blogspot.com/2014/12/greed-explained-j-paul-getty-aristotle.html
LikeLike
Those people that want “just enough” seem to be in a minority. When things get tough they will starve. Those that build a reserve of fat are more likely to survive adverse conditions, even though carrying around and storing the excess has certain costs, especially to Wal-Mart that must provide scooters to our well-endowed corpuscular royalty. The entire evolution of life is focused upon the acquisition of energy and reproduction and I just don’t see any rational or irrational argument that can subvert the greedy subconscious core of our behaviors. Even religions that promote “just enough” have goals that seem counter to their messages.
LikeLike
I recall seeing recently some tv documentary about the Catholic Church in America where light was shed on the fact that embezzlement is a major problem because in each diocese there is only one person in charge of the money. This problem in addition to the pedophilia cases have really rattled the Vatican due to the vast wealth that American Catholicism generates for the Vatican bureaucracy. The current pope has been busy trying to put out these fires with lots of reforms.
‘Too-big-to-fail’ comes to mind.
LikeLike
They all want to grow in influence and power. Clergy cannot repress sexual desire. Victims cannot forgive when there is a jackpot to be had. All corporations want growth and increased profits. People in poor situations still find power in turning out ten children while religious organizations support their maximal procreation. More procreation equals more progeny to be indoctrinated to support the religion. Even totalitarian China could not long enforce the one child policy. Control population through industrialization and you trade the ten child empowerment for the three home, six car and a storage building full of junk empowerment. People want freedom and democracy, the freedom to destroy themselves by electing the reptilian leadership they truly admire.
LikeLike
The exosomatic adaptation to the environment (i.e. technology) is a condition of capitalist carbon man’s existence.
LikeLike
He is rocking the boat to the degree that Koch brothers are preparing for a surreptitious ideological religious war with the Pope.
LikeLike
The one paragraph that sums up a future scenario painted by the Long Emergency (JHK, 2005):
“The picture is further clouded by the notion of substitutability, a doctrine based on the observation that the sensitive device we call the market seems to call forth new resources as old resources become problematic (usually expressed in terms of higher prices). Hence, when trees grew scarce in England during the Little Ice Age (1560-1850), people there began to use more coal to keep warm, which caused people to dig deeper for it, which called forth the innovation of the steam engine to drain water from the mines so the miners wouldn’t drown. However, an interesting positive feedback loop was set in motion. The invention of the steam engine (a magical product of human ingenuity) provoked the invention of other new machines, and then of factories with machines, which prompted the need for better indoor lighting, which stimulated the use of petroleum, which produced brighter light than candles (and was much easier to get than sperm whales), which provoked the development of the oil industry, whose oil was found to work even better in engines than coal did, which led to the massive exploitation of a one-time endowment of concentrated, stored solar energy, which we have directed through pipes of various kinds in an immense flow of entropy, which has resulted in fantastic environmental degradation and human habitat overshoot beyond carrying capacity. It is assumed now that human beings, prompted by the market, will employ ingenuity to discover a substitute for oil and gas, once the price starts to ramp up beyond the “affordable” range. This assumption is apt to prove fallacious because it ignores the fact that the earth is a closed system, while the laws of thermodynamics state that energy can’t be created out of nothing, only changed from low entropy to high entropy, and that we have already changed the half of our oil endowment that was easiest to get into dispersed carbon dioxide, which is now ratcheting up global warming and climate change, which might well put the industrial adventure out of business before human ingenuity can come up with a substitute for oil. The solar energy stored for millions of years in oil will now be expressed in higher temperatures, more severe storms, rising sea levels, and harsher conditions for the human species, which, despite its exosomatic technological achievements, remains a part of nature and subject to its laws.”
LikeLike
Xraymike,
Don’t know if you’ve ever seen this, but you have a champion for your work in the form of self-proclaimed “dumb hippie on a rock” (posted more than a year ago). Very high praise, and deservedly so.
LikeLike
Here it is:
LikeLike
Oh yeah I’ve enjoyed some of his rants. He lives in Austin, a placed I lived in briefly when stationed at the now defunct Bergstrom AFB.
6th Street and Congress was my stomping ground.
Austin, to its detriment, has grown considerably larger since I was there.
LikeLike
“A typology of societies (from hunter-gatherers to agriculturalists using animals to industrial society) reveals a pattern of exosomatic use of energy that increases from 20 GJ per person per year, to 60 GJ per person per year, to 200–300 GJ per person per year (Fischer-Kowalski and Haberl, 2007). The question arises whether the 7,000 million people at present on earth, or the 8,500 million at the estimated ‘peak population’ towards 2050, will have enough available energy to supply the current level of 200–300 GJ per person per year in the very rich societies. This is unlikely.”
http://www.ejolt.org/2012/12/human-energy-use-endosomatic-exosomatic/
LikeLike
It’s coming on Christmas
They’re cutting down trees
They’re putting up reindeer
And singing songs of joy and peace
Oh I wish I had a river
I could skate away on
But it don’t snow here
It stays pretty green
I’m going to make a lot of money
Then I’m going to quit this crazy scene
I wish I had a river
I could skate away on…
LikeLike
When I was a kid in Calgary my dad made our back yard into a mini hockey rink in the fall and winter. We also use to play on community outdoor rinks, frozen rivers, lakes and ponds. Joni is a good Ole Alberta girl……………………………………………………
Canada’s Outdoor Ice Skating Rinks’ Days Are Numbered Thanks to Climate Change
Skating rinks are already open for fewer days in the year than they were just a decade ago
http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/canadas-outdoor-ice-skating-rinks-days-are-numbered-thanks-climate-change-180953719/?no-ist
LikeLike
I almost bought an off-grid house because of that song.
Save The Rainforest — Don’t Wipe Ur Ass
http://truth-out.org/news/item/28232-green-neocolonialism-afro-brazilian-rebellion-in-brazil
LikeLike
Assuming that our self-extinction is a done deal, it begs the question: Was it worth it after all?
Admittedly there were some incredibly beautiful and deeply meaningful realities and creations in the course of this tragic earthly drama. But at the same time we humans have perpetrated the most abominable actions demonstrating a capacity for evil and stupidity unparalleled among living species. We have turned what could perhaps have been a sort of paradise into a living hell doomed to extinguish itself in a holocaust of madness and unlove.
Given that as individuals we have zero chance to turn this grinding machine of death around toward a better future, what are we to say: was it worth it to have ventured life in a universe after all? Would it have been better just to have an insentient machine of mindless energies whirling according to uncaring physical laws towards some meaningless ending?
Finally, what will we pronounce on this checkered affair, a blessing or a curse?
LikeLike
Ain’t nothing but a thing, mike k. The curse is realizing it. The tonic is to embrace absurdity and some small measure of gratitude.
LikeLike
Thanks for your response, Apneaman. I kinda understand where you are coming from, having dwelt in my own version of materialism for many years past. Science is very seductive to the disillusioned. It’s claim to exclusive possession of the real truth and ways of knowing and proving can unfortunately lead to devaluing those dimensions that give life its transcendent beauty and higher meanings.
It takes time and a growing openness to realize that science has major limitations and inner contradictions and blind spots in the project to understand reality. That really, an exclusive dependence on “science” for the full range of human experience is only a philosophical choice, and there are many other avenues into dimensions science has no handle on. I would conclude by suggesting that our possible longer term survival as a species depends less on getting the science right, and more on finding a place within ourselves that understands love and sharing and living simply together in peace and friendship. I no longer feel a need to reduce that to a set of equations, however elegant they might be. But let it be known that I am a BIG fan of Science, and find incredible depth and beauty in it!
LikeLike
I’ve taken good care of this over the years. I would like to re-gift this to everyone for this holiday season.
LikeLike
Not to nitpick, but if it were not for a majority of those “dirty fucking hippies” buying into the capitalist system then we would not have had 50 years of the shop-until-you-drop mentality that has implicitly created many of the injustices portrayed in the video.
I dunno, maybe I’m way off base here, but I thought it was common knowledge that most if not all of the 75 million so-called baby boomers in America got over their “rebellious youth” phase and after something like a hangover in the early to mid 70’s proceeded to settle down to build families in suburban subdivisions and build careers in corporate cubicles.
Hippie Chicks cum Soccer Moms. “Sex, drugs, and rock n’ roll” gives way to “Saturday Night Fever” and then eventually the ultimate sell-out of “Greed is Good” as brought to you by Wall Street and the so-called Regan Revolution.
Case in point? I couldn’t help but notice that the “flower power” VW bug pictured in the video has a Nokia corporate logo prominently displayed on the right front wheel well.
LikeLike
It was only a small percent of boomers that were actually hippies. As a group their parents were probably more rebellious than their boomer kids were. For example, the majority of Vietnam vets volunteered where as the majority of the greatest generation, WWII vets had to be drafted and if Rosie the Riveters and other labor were as happily patriotic as Hollywood and the U.S. government leads everyone to believe then why all the pre and post war strikes? I mean no disrespect to the sacrifices made by that generation, but the reality is much more complicated and gray than the propaganda suggests. Was that generation of people better than us today? Maybe, but every generation since has been born into a later stage of a cancer that started long ago.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2007/12/30/427672/-The-Great-Strike-Wave-of-1946
LikeLike
Commodify Your Dissent by Dead Milkmen
Who will sponsor the next revolution?
Who will buy the rights to the next class war?
Purchase the t-shirts and the audio version of the book
They took your anger and polished it up
And they sold it back to you
They took your anger and repackaged it
And there’s nothing you can do
Designer names on army uniforms
A dash of subversion will make your move a sell
You’ll capture that “indie” feel that the kids are crazy for
They took your frustrations and dressed them up
Before a focus group
They painted your frustrations in earth tone colors
And there’s nothing you can do
Country music used to be about the music, not about the country
There once was a time when rap was dangerous
Now flag-waving idiots and millionaire illiterates dance across the screen
Johnny Cash died for you
This sense of outrage could be yours if the price is right
Poetry and galleries are now Jingles and cartoons
Oh this is the river in which we’ve learned to swim
Sub-culture vultures circle above
The great unread white and blue
And there’s nothing, nothing you can do
Country music used to be about the music, not about the country
There once was a time when rap was dangerous
Now flag-waving idiots and millionaire illiterates dance across the screen
Jam Master Jay died for you
C’mon Bourgeoisie and get behind me
Captains of industry I’m waiting for your calls
Operators are standing by so don’t delay
Your parents are reading hipster lit
And they try to dress like you
They took your anger and repackaged it
And there’s nothing you can do
Punks, Goths, and Rivetheads disappeared into the mall
Along with the yuppies, and the beatniks, and the freaks
Oh this is the river in which we’ve learned to swim
And this is the river in which we will all drown
LikeLike
‘Oh this is the river in which we’ve learned to swim,
and this is the river in which we will all drown’
I’m reading ‘Future Primitive Revisited’ by John Zerzan. I haven’t read him before.
From the introduction by Michael Becker::
‘Many critics of industrial civilisation use the metaphor of a speeding train heading for a wreck. By Zerzan’s account we might say that civilisation is like a vast hole,with the living participants being consigned,collectively, to the inescapable role of “digger.”
The rule is that salvation can be found only through more efficient and relentless means of digging; the participants experience the mute horror of watching natural light recede while engineers design artificial lighting and air conditioning systems. An increasingly powerful legal-bureaucratic-managerial authority promise a vast array of material pleasure as the reward for digging, poverty and insecurity for those who refuse to dig, and severe repression for those who sabotage the digging apparatus. When the workers dig deeply enough they will discover an underground river called Styx(hatred) and its confluence with other rivers, including Lethe (forgetfulness and oblivion), and these will mark their crossing over from life to death. And the shovels will be taken from their hands and replaced with oars, and their training in digging will suit them perfectly for rowing with metronomic precision. And they will pull endlessly along this dark river, forgetting there was ever a world of sun,green earth,and air. And with these metaphors civilisation will think it is indicting the dark, prehistoric world. But really it is only indicting its own efforts at constructing an entirely man-made environment where “misery is the river of the world” and everybody rows.
LikeLike
Another way to think of it is that the price of a ticket on the train of life is to accept that the trip will end with your death. What’s important is to enjoy the ride, and try to do something good for your fellow passengers along the way. Beyond that, there is no guarantee that there won’t be some major bumps along the way, or that you will ever completely understand why you came to be on this train…. But I did get chosen to play a very minor bit role in this tragic cosmic opera, and that’s something!
LikeLike
I am going to risk one more comment, even though I sense that the hall monitor is sending a disaproving look my way, which I am pretending not to notice. I really do care. So in spite of needing to take refuge in objectivity and nonattachment quite often, I will return to this and other sites dealing with the awful future we are creating. I value being conscious of the tragedy we are enacting, and refuse to close my eyes to live in fantasy and denial.
LikeLike
I’ve just been reading Joe Romm’s last post at Climate Progress. Joe thinks that if we have the right policies in place, we can quickly reduce atmospheric CO2 levels from 450ppm to 350 ppm. Where did he get that from? Seems like deluded optimism to me. Some of the comments to that are reassuring, though. For instance, there has been no warming since 1998. That’s a relief.(joke)
LikeLike
Joe’s brain won’t let him believe in the apocalypse.
LikeLike
Doesn’t he have a daughter about seven years old? I wouldn’t believe in the apocalypse either if I had a young daughter. Ah, whom am I kidding? Of course, I would!
LikeLike
I just read more of the comments to the above article. The last comment by Kevin Hester said a similar comment to my comment above. He states: ‘Understating the severity of the problem is the new denial’
LikeLike
Been lying low for the last few weeks as it seems a never ending barrage of horrendous situations continue occurring.
I can’t quite believe that in the midst of peak oil we (or those who can) are allowing the price of oil to drop to such levels. Hey, it’s like turning on the taps in San Paulo or CA and just letting them run and run and run believing that what comes out will do so forever.
How the Saudi’s can hope to support their welfare state (whose population just keeps growing) while their income keeps dropping is beyond my capacity for understanding? It’s like lighting a match while you’re standing next to a gasoline pump (like that scene in Alfred Hitchcock’s The Birds). Can anyone really believe the outcome for the Saudi’s is going to be good in either the short or long run?
It’s been quite “interesting” (really horrifying ) here in NYC especially the last few weeks as I’m sure many of you reading here know. It was only a short distance from where I live that the murder of the two police officers occurred and our Mayor seems to be taking the brunt of the backlash for not supporting the police.
Are we not in a police state yet?
All of a sudden Permaculturists want to talk about racists. When I raised the issue years ago when organizing and offering PDC courses I was told by the “official” leaders of the movement that Permaculture doesn’t do politics. Of course whether Permaculture does politics doesn’t matter to politics. It’s like trying to debate with water whether it will boil at 212 F. So now that the horse and most of the barn’s animals have escaped, Permaculture want’s to open dialogue on the topic of racism. Wonder when they will decide that Industrial Civ can’t be saved and that encouraging people to have babies is not a good idea.
Last week on Saturday I came out of the gym planning to walk a block along Fifth Ave to 12th St to pick up some books on hold at the Jefferson Branch of NYPL (this location was actually once a prison). It’s my usual routine when I’ve got books waiting for me at the branch. I was shocked as I turned onto Fifth. There was a tidal wave of people marching uptown. As I no longer participate in these type of events, I’m not as in the loop as I was once.
Trying to cross Fifth to get to the west side of the street seemed an overwhelming task and it took me until getting to 9th St before the march stopped for a moment, allowing me and a few others to cross through the throng.
As I walked down Fifth though there were the boys in blue lined up along the sidewalks watching and I kept looking at them as they watched. I saw some interesting faces. This was before the murders in Brooklyn. I was trying to keep my eyes down as my own temper is on hair trigger these days and I could have easily gotten into it with anyone. Well I had to look up in order to navigate the sidewalk and my eyes and the eyes of a short muscular white police office caught each other. It’s almost for certain he was of Italian descent (but he could have been Hispanic as well).
He nodded to me in a way that seemed to communicate that we were allies of some sort. Hey, we’re both white. He was a hunk, but I’m a shell of what I once was, so I found it hard to believe he appreciated my looks. Hard to believe up to two years ago I used to swim a mile a day and bike a century on weekends. Of course with all the energy flowing around I could have been projecting something completely in my head, but I’ve had similar situations where people project on to me an alliance with them (hetros at the gym, Jews at work places, whites in other situations).
I really wanted to take one of the protestors aside and ask them whether they believed in Climate Change, Peak Oil, Limits to Growth and OverPopulation, but thought it best in this instance to just continue on to the library where the second volume of Morris Berman’s trilogy about the collapse of the American Empire was waiting for me.
In the week since then I’ve had interesting experiences with two different black men (both gay; one at the gym and other other on a bus heading up Madison Ave) that saddened and would have at one time shocked me. Oddly enough I’ve had the best experiences with two bus drives, both black (one man and one woman), in the last two weeks that left me feeling that within the mob are some people who get what’s going on. I’ll try to write and share more about these experiences later.
In the meantime I found this piece on Mark Evanier’s News From Me site to be quite insightful and very much in line that too many of us probably have become or know someone like the little boy Travis that Evanier writes about. Every once in a while Mark actually seems to penetrate the veil of illusion he lives and works within the Entertainment Industry.
The Travis Story
Published Monday, December 22, 2014 at 8:18 PM
http://www.newsfromme.com/2014/12/22/travis-story/
LikeLike
LikeLike
This treasure of posts and comments will be in my mind for years to come. I suppose it could be worse. It’s like starting over, erasing many of my archaic assumptions and reconstructing a philosophy of existence without rancor or pitiful depression, an attempt to “come to terms” with what seems to be apocalypse. The task is daunting.
Long live the reformation.
LikeLike
Alchemy is slow work, much of it in darkness away from the glare of surface consciousness. Trust in the unknown, the yet to be revealed. Is there any other game in town worth playing? When you have everything to lose, why not just bet it all?
LikeLike
Merry Christmas to my fellow prognosticators of crashes, collapse and the apocalypse.
We few, we depressed few, we band of doomers.
LikeLike
A gift given to me. The sides of the box say: “Bye, bye Belgium” and “Where’s Florida?”
The top of the box says: “You’ve Got the Whole World in Your Hand and it’s sinking…
LikeLike
i want that fuckn cup
LikeLike
Posted on Twitter:

LikeLike
Christmas present from today’s news in the Siberian Times…
LikeLike
opening presents can rip ur nails
LikeLike
H/T Carl_Schmitt on Reddit…
Another blog worth following:
http://www.roughtype.com/
LikeLike
Completely decoupled from reality.
……………………………………………………
Everything Is Awesome!
http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/12/everything-is-awesome-113801.html?hp=t3_r#.VJt6dsAKA
LikeLike
Nobody want to hear that our carbon-based civilization is irredeemable and inconsistent with a livable planet.
LikeLike
This is really all that matters…
LikeLike
ozzie says the world spent about $2 trillion on green power so far, and emissions go up faster than ever.
LikeLike
Christmas heat breaks records across Atlantic Canada
http://www.theweathernetwork.com/news/articles/christmas-heat-breaks-records-across-atlantic-canada/42547/
LikeLike
Thought you might like this Mike.
LikeLike
Nice video and the answer to the question posed in the last moments of the video is apparent in daily headlines.
We’ve already passed the moment of opportunity when we could have pulled ourselves ashore. We kept steadfast on our course along the river of Denial and into the jagged maw awaiting us at the bottom of the roaring waterfalls.
LikeLike
Rising Oceans Force Bangladeshi Farmers Inland for New Jobs
“He makes about $4 a day if he’s lucky, and most of that goes to buy food for his family of four. ”
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-12-25/rising-oceans-force-bangladesh-farmers-to-look-inland-for-jobs.html
Received my typical haul of Consumermass presents as “gift cards”, one of them being $20 for Tim Horton’s (Dough-nuts & Coffee). That equals what the farmers family spends on food for 5 days. I bet $20 worth of apple fritters and Boston cremes is three weeks of calories for them. Hard times in the land of plenty.
LikeLike
Homo Collosus rules by brute strength of superior technologic killing machines and rationalizes/justifies its gluttonous way of existence by staging all reality through the sophisticated media apparatus of corporate propaganda. Your consent is manufactured and enforced.
LikeLike
@apneaman
LikeLike
Lol. Freaky and somewhat reminiscent of DEVO from my early teenage years, but much darker according to the times.
LikeLike
Seemingly “protected” by their privileged status and money, the elite’s disconnect with reality is evident once again in this headline:
Malaysia floods: More than 160,000 flee homes; anger as PM plays golf in US during crisis
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-12-27/anger-mounts-as-malaysia-hit-by-worst-floods-in-decades/5989870
LikeLike
Brazil Drought:
Water levels at Cantareira & Alto Tiete reservoirs, serving 11 million, have fallen to 6.7% & 10.3% of capacity, respectively.
http://fw.to/KD5MYJV
“Rationing is happening in Sao Paulo city, no matter what the authorities say.”
LikeLike
It’s the middle of the wet season there right now. Could be big trouble when the dry season comes. In addition to water shortages for drinking, cooking, washing, etc, Brazil needs water for hydroelectric generation. 75-80% of their power is generated this way…or was. I think at best, Brazil can only kick the can on their water predicaments for a few years before it blows up on them.
According to the often overly optimistic EIA:
“Brazil has spent more than $5 billion to subsidize electric utilities replacing lost hydroelectric generation with fossil fuel-fired generation, including large amounts of liquefied natural gas, and has taken steps to provide backup generation for stadiums.”
http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=16731
LikeLike
LikeLike
I think many here would find the Clark and Dawe video on growth amusing. Only a few minutes. Go to the mahb homepage,
Good essay. Thanks TDOS and Mike.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Thanks,Apneaman.
LikeLike
Website of Helmut Lubbers (America2.0):
http://www.ecoglobe.ch/home/e/index.htm
http://www.ecoglobe.ch/politics/e/do-ngos-help.htm
Witness the growth spurt in non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and you would be forgiven for thinking the world becomes a more caring place every day.
These legions of not-for-profit groupings that fan out across the world, intent on ‘capacity building’, ‘reducing poverty’ and ensuring that the ‘voices of the most marginalized’ are heard, surely reflect an acceptance that too many have suffered for too long, and the tide can turn with the right kind of wind behind it.
History, however, teaches us that the exact opposite may be true.
Whereas organized charities go back over 100 years, the term non-governmental organization is more recent, dating to the formation of the United Nations in 1945, when a select club of international non-state agencies were awarded observer status to some of its meetings. The common factor uniting this group, apart from the fact that they were neither government agencies nor businesses in the traditional sense, is that they would have an avowed mission to work for a social good – whether it was as torchbearers for human rights, the environment or just old-fashioned ‘development’ (a new-fangled idea back then).
Fast forward a few decades and we witness an explosion of NGOs. The spur was the rise of neo-liberal ideology, eventually enshrined in the Reagan-Thatcher years. Predatory capitalism and the so-called free market were the answer; government needed to be hands-off with regard to all notions of public provision (health care, education, the lot).
Increasingly, governments began looking to NGOs to provide cheap services, a role that continues to grow with austerity policies.
However, rarely does government funding to NGOs match the cuts. Aid to ‘developing’ nations also began increasingly to be funneled via NGOs rather than through government organs — between 1975 and 1985 the amount of aid taking this NGO route shot up by 1,400 percent.
With the fragmentation of the Left under the neo-liberal attack, much of the energy that could have gone into fighting the power went into forming the NGO — they became repositories of a residual idealism still reeling from the onslaught. Arundhati Roy describes the transformation achieved: ‘Armed with their billions, these NGOs have waded into the world, turning potential revolutionaries into salaried activists, funding artists, intellectuals and filmmakers, gently luring them away from radical confrontation.’
Today, 30 new ones are formed every day in Britain; and there are 1.5 million in the US alone. Fully 90 percent of currently existing NGOs have been launched since 1975. Roy calls them ‘an indicator species’, saying: ‘It’s almost as though the greater the devastation caused by neo-liberalism, the greater the outbreak of NGOs.’…
…More serious are the charges that they NGOize popular resistance movements, acting as unelected spokespersons, deflecting energy away from confrontation with self-help projects and the like, and dividing communities struggling against dispossession. ‘They take sections of people into their fold,’ said one Indian activist, ‘and restrict their concern for these people, while others do not exist. They breed small hopes, solve small issues and take small actions while the movement process is attempting to address the larger issues of displacement facing all our people, NGO beneficiary or not.’…
LikeLike
Good comment. Thanks. I like the Roy quotes.
LikeLike
TDOS in the essay above mentions that things will be getting worse before they get better. I would like to think that is correct. The more probable course seems to me that on the climate and just about every front,things will get progressively worse. Ecologically knowledgeable people have been warning about our current situation for decades, to no avail. The last slim hope of retaining a livable climate and productive ocean ecosystem is to stop all use of fossil fuels now, accept the enormous population die off, and for the survivors to not use fossil fuels at all.
99% of people reading this would say ‘That is absurd, it will never happen’, and of course they are correct. The alternative course, by continuing the use of fossil fuels, will still result in an enormous population die-off later this century, possibly before mid century, but with huge climate related problems around the planet, and an altered, acidified, unproductive ocean ecosystem as well.
LikeLike
Which is why appealing to so called leaders, or even appealing to the general masses, is not the course of action to take.
LikeLike
Appealing to the leaders or masses is asking those causing our problems to admit their resposibility and to change their behavior drastically. No way is that going to happen. They all think their way is the right and only way to go. Fundamentalism is unfortunately not restricted to a few religious sects. Curing folks of zombie conformism is a long and difficult task that requires their willing cooperation. There is no chance that this will happen in any meaningful time frame. We are set to be cooked in our own juice, literally….
LikeLike
People may be genetically predisposed to follow leaders that are chosen, not based upon their actual leadership qualities and intelligence, but rather the appearance of success including beautiful hair, nice teeth, fine accouterments, and a nice smile. People often don’t think, they follow, and the ruthless amongst us take advantage of that trust and primitive system of evaluation and selection to lead followers down the path to ruin. Most people, unable, or unwilling to think, are looking for a messiah amongst deceitful sociopaths. They’re looking for a Third Reich or New American Century or Hope and Change or a Caliphate and so on while the leader promotes the agenda of those that control wealth and resources. “Zombie conformists” is an apt description and even with an unprecedented promotion of education we still have a vast majority of believers, unable to sort things out, looking for an authority figure to lead them out of the desert. The first thing students should learn is that humans are dissipative and thirst for energy and resources, that evolution does not make humans fully moral and trustworthy, and that they’d better learn to think for themselves instead of putting their fate into the hands of those that would destroy them.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Interesting post and comments here:
Two viable futures
…
My comment (awaiting moderation):
People have to understand the fact that the total destruction of Earth’s cryospheric regions has already been set into motion and continues to be extensively documented by scientists. These cryospheric regions are what regulated jet streams, hydrologic cycles, weather patterns, and the very biospheric conditions that have allowed our existing biota to evolve and thrive. This is all going away at a rapid clip and, along with other catastrophic practices such as industrial farming and deforestation for palm oil, accelerating the 6th mass extinction. The rate of change is too fast for species to successfully adapt. Speed kills.
I imagine there might be some survivors, but they will likely be the very wealthy who have been able to relocate and establish small communities at the poles.
“Some scientists are indicating we should make plans to adapt to a 4C world. While prudent, one wonders what portion of the living population now could adapt to such a world, and my view is that it’s just a few thousand people [seeking refuge] in the Arctic or Antarctica.” ~ Atmospheric and marine scientist Ira Leifer in 2013
LikeLike
I read leavergirl’s reply to you….she don’t get it. She is choosing not to. Anyone who mentions the paleo climate record, the laws of: physics, chemistry and biology is deemed a “false prophet” and comparisons to Guy McPherson are invoked. This has become the typical response for the Doomer lite crowd. Lots of parroting of Greer, KMO and the others who cannot/will not except that human extinction is even physically possible. Their brains won’t allow it? The whole piece is just wishful thinking. She lays out 4 Doomer lite scenarios and picks the one that makes her feel best; the one she “prefers”. The fact that all the other mass extinction events were preceded by huge spikes in CO2 is not included or allowed. “My preferred future ..”, “I would prefer something more… broadly inspiring, complex and preservationist”, and the final rejection to you, “Well, if we are cooked, then what’s the point of doing anything?” Screw that”. If you listen to Greer, KMO, Kunstler, Scribbler, leavergirl and many other Doomer lites you will see a pattern of preferred futures and plans. I’m not saying extinction is 100% guaranteed, but extinctions from climate change are the rule on this planet and to insist [“Screw that”] that it cannot happen and therefore must be shoved under the rug is the height of magical thinking. Or maybe it is just what most humans brains will not allow. Same thing?
LikeLike
Excellent comment. Perhaps your most insightful.
Anthropocentrism is killing us.
LikeLike
Good comments. Only, I do not think that todays wealthy/elite will be tomorrows wealthy/elite. Bankers and captains of industry/tech are not really suitable for what is coming. Who knows, maybe there is a clever adaptable war leader among them? Beware the Praetorian Guard 1%ers and beware the mob.
LikeLike
My additional 2 cents:
Capitalist industrial civilization is irredeemable and incompatible with a livable planet. This is a message that falls on deaf ears because we are all, in one way or another, dependent upon it for our jobs and current way of life. So we like to believe that there’s a techno-fix just around the corner or that we will somehow be able to adapt to a denuded planet or that God or Gaia has something else in store for us.
We are undergoing a shift in the earth’s climate that will likely include periods of abrupt climate change more severe than what is currently happening in the Arctic. Ice cores have shown that this has happened numerous times in earth’s history (for example, up to 5-10°C per year during the Bølling Warming in what is now northern Greenland). No exceptions will be made for modern man. Such knowledge of our dire predicament is no excuse to do nothing. On the contrary, we should be implementing global efforts at wartime speed to stop and reverse this trend… Yet indicators of environmental health continue to plummet and capitalist industrial civilization rolls on unabated…
Worldwide Coal Production Continues Growing
If we’re not burning it, we’re loading it on barges and shipping it abroad
http://therealnews.com/t2/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=31&Itemid=74&jumival=12909
LikeLike
13 minute clip with Dr. Peter Ward that says it all.
Everything you need to know about Mass Extinction, Sea Level Rise and Amplification
LikeLike
Guys like Kunstler and Greer have a readership to cultivate.
If their vision of the future is too dark, they won’t sell books (some of which are fiction, for fuck’s sake).
If their forecast is too quick (irony that they make a living on something called ‘collapse), it’ll scare people away. After years of writing, both of these men have reached the point of diminishing returns. Their blogs are repetitive. I still enjoy them, if only to see how many different ways they can describe the myth of progress.
Greer’s relying on Toynbee’s 3 1/2 step formula for collapse. I’m not sold on it. Complex systems can crash in a hurry. It’s an open question. He also finds some issue with Tainter, though he’s never specified what that is. I find it curious since he owes Tainter for enunciating the basic tenets of Greer’s catabolic collapse. Aside from Tainter, I found Quigley’s survey of civilization better than Toynbee’s and Spengler’s.
Apneaman’s comments wouldn’t pass the filter on Greer’s site, which is replete with sychophantic parroting. Greer is in the business of entertainment. When he took a hiatus, the collapse porn junkees were in withdrawal.
After Orlov had no more collapse books in progress, he came out and said preparation is basically useless. I don’t see the harm, though I have no pretentions that I’ll be saved.
LikeLike
A cell may have several different pathways to accomplish metabolic ends, but if something essential with no substitutes is knocked-out, the cell dies. A cell may also be poisoned, with ricin for instance, and the entire protein-building enterprise is shut down almost immediately. Immediate collapse of a technological society would probably require a complete loss of the electrical grid or an unprecedentedly harsh pandemic. The loss of oil can be compensated for by several other pathways, although at much lower levels of metabolic activity that would result in a slow and insurmountable death spiral. Humans with food and water could spend a long time watching their society and its infrastructure deteriorate before their eyes, sort of like sentient molecules within a cell that no longer functions, inside a body that no longer breathes, just a slow and relentless breakdown of all structure and complexity within a miasma of toxic gases. (Humans may get to deal with CO2, methane, and hydrogen sulfide sprinkled with radioactive isotopes.) But why worry, just work hard and pay your interest and taxes, your leaders are taking care of business, literally, and that’s all that counts.
LikeLike
The loss of oil can’t be compensated for without huge disruptions to the system. There are no qualifications. There is no compensation. The system, as is, will collapse. Also, I’m not sure the biological metaphor for society is appropriate. They are both complex, but different. The petrol economy and its scale might present a divisive shift in history. I maintain that its sudden end is possible. If I’m betting, I go with a slower and steadier decline, but you never know.
LikeLike
Everything that has occurred in the evolution of technological society has also occurred much, much earlier in cells. There is a one-to-one correspondence in major functional categories. This knowledge is meaningless to a bunch of dumbshit apes running on automatic, gloating in their obvious superiority vis-a-vis other life and believing that they’re truly different, the chosen ones. You betcha they’re the chosen ones, the metastatic ones. There’s always a trade-off in efficiency versus resiliency with regards to how many alternative pathways that can be carried about, ready to be deployed when needed. I think humans will wish they had made their systems more robust with more energy options, but perhaps there really are no further options to support such a massive, malignant and complex growth.
LikeLike
Toby Hemmingway was in NYC and the NYC area about 6 years ago. The first was a presentation in Manhattan and the second was running a PDC upstate at an Ashram in the Catskill.
This was a pre-cancer Toby whose ideas and ideology were much different. He insisted and the audience (each and everyone) ate it up that complex systems can’t just collapse. That part and parcel of that entity is that other parts of the system will come into play to make up for weakness in other parts. I believe he used the human body as an example.
I argued that this was a load of crap with nothing to support this belief. If anything, complex systems are more dangerous and delicate that if a part breaks it could actually bring down the whole system. The problem was how to find out where the weak link was and correct if you still could. My example was that there is nothing in the human body to take the place of the heart. The heart is not like human skin cells that keep dying and growing throughout one’s life. Once the heart stops for a long enough time, it’s game over.
Watching Toby change over the years has been an interesting side show. Could this type of evolution happen to Greer, Kunstler and Martenson? It’s always possible, but I’d say highly unlikely.
LikeLike
If a complex system, i.e. the globalized industrial civilization of humans, is built upon the delicate, shifting sand dunes of the earth’s climate system, then pray to God you are not alive when the winds really start to howl.
LikeLike
One of the wealthy countries had to blink first on sea level rise. Tough economic times in the home country of the former British empire. Privileged Floridians properties are still being protected and insured courtesy the tax payer…..for now. That too will end.
………………………………………………………………………………
Almost 7,000 UK properties to be sacrificed to rising seas
Properties worth over £1bn will be lost to coastal erosion in England and Wales over the next century, with no compensation for homeowners, as it becomes too costly to protect them
http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/dec/28/7000-uk-properties-sacrificed-rising-seas-coastal-erosion
LikeLike
Just a matter of time…
It would take a temperature rise of 18° Fahrenheit (10° Celsius) before forests starts to grow again in Greenland.
http://www.livescience.com/49224-greenland-ice-sheet-melt-changing.html
Time to try and push out another post before the year’s end. We’re reaching the 100 comments marker.
LikeLike
So, I wondered a few weeks ago how Saudi Arabia could be dumb enough to risk the wrath of the huge numbers of youth being subsidized by their oil sales to stay controlled.
I did not see how the drop in oil prices could be a good thing in a number of areas.
Well, it’s always great to be ahead of the curve, I only wished it paid off like a Trifecta at the track.
On December 27, 2014 from the New Zealand Herald
Fears of youth unrest as oil price slump forces Saudi cutbacks
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=11379346
A few months ago on August 31, 2014 at the Daily Impact Tom Lewis had this piece
The Scariest Picture in the World
http://www.dailyimpact.net/2014/08/31/the-scariest-picture-in-the-world/#more-2363
Whether we go completely extinct or are only down to a few thousand, it’s the journey that will be full of horror. Not a single solitary person will have the luxury of not being attached.
I witnessed people not attached to their more rational natures last Friday and Saturday right here close to the Queens/Brooklyn border. The bus I take to get to a branch of the Brooklyn Public Library runs along Myrtle Avenue. That’s the street the funeral parlor for Ramirez was held. Well, both days were full of chaos and tension.
I had no idea that the buses were only going 13 blocks from where I pick it up and then were no runnings into Brooklyn. There were no signs affixed to the bus stop I use so that I might have avoided wasting the 20 minute wait for a bus I was only on for about 5 minutes.
Before deciding to walk back to the main thorough fair and get another bus to take me to the train, I was waiting at the Bus stop which would take me back to my starting point. At the stop were a few people all pretty frustrated. Both the driver, for the bus heading back, a Hispanic Woman about 45 years old and a young white male in his mid thirties (probably of Irish descent) were all talking about the murder of the two cops. Not the murder of the blacks, but the murder of the cops. These three were having a full on raging rant about DeBlasio.
It appeared that a fight had broken out at the viewing. A heated and emotional interaction between two people focused on the details of the murder and lead to a fist fight breaking out between these two. Hey, it’s lucky that a full on riot didn’t break out. It really is like throwing a match on a combustible material.
It was all his fault. The Hispanic woman starting going up and down the queue asking in a loud challenging voice if people had voted for DeBalsio. I debated whether to explain to her my vote was private and was not her business, tell her it didn’t matter who was in office. All that went through my mind was those who were questioned during HUAC or the years I would deny being gay when asked by those who were looking to humiliate me.
These people were so detached from themselves it reminded me of my Buddhist teacher who screwed everything in a dress. When his wife stated how hurt she was, he was the calm focused point of rationalization stating she was too attached to him. Of course that he was disrespectful towards here was not a valid argument.
I’m an emotional person. I think emotions are good, but do not think acting on them is a good thing. To express one’s feeling takes great courage and is usually met with some derision by others who think it’s weak and cowardly. Yet to know what one is feeling and state it is much different than to be so caught up in those feelings and try to avoid stating them we cause much damage.
I took a few moments while listening to the interaction at the bus stop. Weighed my options and decided the 15 minute walk back to my starting point was the best course of action. I had an option, there may come a time and place when I don’t, despite what is in my best interest.
I hope some people read that story of Travis I linked to in my previous post. There seems to be more and more Travis’s where ever I go these days. His dad must be proud.
LikeLike
PMB: if people could only internalize and play out their emotional reactions and be open to “push-back” or rebuttal (counter arguments) much of the unnecessary craziness could be avoided. It seems we’re not only emotional but irrational, spontaneous and too quick to jump to conclusions that may not be the case. i’m convinced that we don’t have a choice – that we’re decidedly NOT in control of anything, but instead deluded into thinking we are – that we have “choices” and “free will.” We seem to be just another reactive part of the complex systems in which we find ourselves embedded. Thanks for your thoughts and links.
LikeLike
I’ve come to a similar conclusion. I think the notions of free will and self-determination have the appearance of reality during a civilization’s gestation and expansion phases, when there is more opportunity and social mobility. As things calcify, instruments becoming institutions that serve their own ends, the facade is harder to maintain. Human existence has always been contingent and constrained by circumstances. These ‘free’ notions are illusions, narrow windows of perception with a limited range of influence during times of transient prosperity.
Taoi texts were written in a time of troubles. A sage hesitates before speaking.
LikeLike
Take the example of the Achaeans, those Bronze Age invaders who eventually supplanted the Minoan civilization on Crete to create a hybrid we call Mycenaean. As Homer depicted, for a time,they enjoyed their unearned wealth, free from material concerns, the problems of production, or population pressures, showing no understanding or sympathy for the submerged lower classes who support them. These are aristocratic heros priding in individualism and personal glory. Sound familiar? Watch any lone hero Hollywood movie and you’ll see the same thing. This ethos is in stark contrast to the Minoan neolithic garden cultures/fertility rites, which were less free and tied to the land.
Whenever a group hits on a novel way to accumulate, there’s a respite from contraints and the illusion of freedom – for a select few.
Western civilization hit the bonanza of freedom from contraints when they tapped big oil.
As per Hornborg, here are the modes of accumulation:
a)plunder
b)merchant capitalism (exploitation of cultural differences in how goods are evaluated – buy cheap and sell dear)
c)financial capitalism (the servicing of debts; interest)
d)undercompensation of labor
1) coercion (slavery)
2) reciprocity (asymmetric transfer of labor time/land embodied in goods)
3) redistribution – more tribute/taxes flow to power centers than flow out
4) wage labor (c.f. Polanyi’s work)
e)underpayment for resources
LikeLike
Anchorage, Alaska never saw a day below zero in 2014
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/12/30/anchorage-alaska-never-saw-a-day-below-zero-in-2014/
LikeLike
Let’s end the year with a piece focusing on the illusion of progress.
The golden quarter
Some of our greatest cultural and technological achievements took place between 1945 and 1971. Why has progress stalled?
http://aeon.co/magazine/science/why-has-human-progress-ground-to-a-halt/
May progress as we’ve come to know die as rapidly as possible, and I’m well aware what the outcome of this will be in terms of the ensuing chaos and horror.
LikeLike
Nice video for the New Year…
LikeLike
Anthropologist Ted Fischer interviews anthropologist Arthur Demarest.
The Indiana Jones of collapsed cultures: Our Western civilization itself is a bubble
“With apologies to the green movement, ‘sustainability’ is a myth.”
“No society can sustain unlimited growth – none ever has. History demonstrates that expectations of infinite growth lead to collapse.”
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/making-sense/indiana-jones-collapsed-cultures-western-civilization-bubble/
Extended audio interview
http://www.tedfischer.org/category/thinktank/
LikeLike
Previous civilisations that have collapsed have still left behind an inhabitable climate. and a productive ocean ecosystem.That is the main difference between those collapses and the one that will probably occur this century.
In the second last paragraph of the pbs interview,Demarest fudges the issue.As if changing to a’ somewhat lower level of growth ‘is going to provide a solution.He needs to read some Albert Bartlett or some of Tom Murphy’s posts at ‘Do The Math.’
It is too late to change the faulty foundations of the institutions of our civilisation.Thomas Piketty has just refused an award.from the French government and wants it to encourage more growth.So much for Piketty’s insights into the fundamental problems with our bubble civilisation.
LikeLike
If were so awful at long term planning, why did we choose agriculture? Lot’s of risk there with no guaranteed benefit.
LikeLike
We chose agriculture because we’re lousy at long term planning. ‘Twas a grievous error and we are now reaping what was sown.
“Man has lost the capacity to foresee and to forestall. He will end by destroying the earth.”
Albert Schweitzer
LikeLike
I don’t think humans ever possessed that capacity. Agriculture’s adoption probably wasn’t a conscious choice by neolithic garden cultures; rather, it was a gradual change probably due in part to overhunting – another example of humanity’s lack of foresight. I don’t think we can attach too much blame on this. It’s hard to see the future.
LikeLike
Some people plan for 30 year mortgages. Some people intentionally eat healthy so they can eat longer (good plan). Some people have long term retirement savings plans. Many governments have retirement plans and medical plans. In fact they have these plans because citizens insisted on them. People pay for insurance as a back up plan to secure their long term plans. When it comes to climate change we all of a sudden have no ability to plan.
LikeLike
“When it comes to climate change we all of a sudden have no ability to plan.”
That is how I see it as well. In addition though I’d add other things to that list as well. Spoke to a lifeguard at the gym (45th St location) who is from Trinidad. It’s literally like night and day between him (without a college education) and the young Hispanic boy (with the college education) at the 13th St location. It’s possible to have more in-depth conversations with him about a wide variety of topics.
When he and I talked about the current outbreak of protests and anger over the racial issues he was in a quandary regarding why is there so much outrage now. He didn’t understand why are people just now pushing back and hadn’t done it years before. There is not an easy answer to that. To me it’s been like watching a pot slowly simmer over the last 40 years, if not simmer over the last 400 years. That water has to reach boiling at some point if the fire under it gets hot enough.
Netflix finally got copies of a documentary not seen since it was shown on a single night back in 1970, King: A Filmed Record… Montgomery to Memphis. I’ve been trying to get hold of a copy for months now since hearing an interview about it. It really does trace the years from the early 50’s through 68. It’s a stunning visual record of what events and challenges went on during those years. Sadly, I don’t think things have gotten better in the years since 68, but much worse.
Of course during those years there were leaders like Medgar Evers, Malcolm X and the work of the Black Panthers in their local communities. So King wasn’t alone.
After the reading the piece I linked to regarding progress it took me a while to get my blood-pressure down as the author went in an direction I was completely not expecting. I assumed he had a better grasp on the situation we are facing today, yet his reasons for why we haven’t progressed much since 1971 were completely off the mark.
I got to that piece from reading the post at Hipcrime Vocab and that poster’s response was a rebuttal to the piece at AEON. http://hipcrime.blogspot.com/2014/12/progress-and-predictions.html.
LikeLike
Some would say that humans are the only animals that do possess that quality. Surviving in the wild, as an integral part of the natural order, doesn’t really demand long term planning. And that all depends upon what one means by “long term“.
Adaption is more of a rapid response tactic and that’s what works best for enabling a species to exist sustainably within a closed system.
The human species, if all of its most ancient know ancestors are considered, managed to survive for some five or six million years. It persisted and evolved, until around fifteen to ten thousand years ago, in unimaginably hostile environments, assailed by predators and beleaguered by natural disasters of incomprehensible magnitude.
After enduring these tribulations for thousands of millennia, as an integral part of the natural world, Homo sapiens suddenly, very recently in geological time, deliberately abandoned its almost incredibly successful branch of the evolutionary path and took a fork down a one way road that has brought us to the brink of extinction in a mere ten thousand years.
In my opinion, our species stopped evolving some time during the transition from the Paleolithic to the Neolithic. Instead of evolving, adapting to environmental change, we began changing the environment to suit our preferences. Some consequences of this destructive, non-adaptive method of survival have been the cessation of the evolutionary process, the loss of adaptive ability and severe, extensive damage to the global environment.
As to “blame” for the spawning of “agriculture“; I think “religion may have had something to do with it.
Archaeological evidence from locations such as Gobekli Tepe, in southeastern Turkey, indicates that, around eleven thousand years ago, Neolithic humans started building large structures, temples, places for ritualistic gatherings. At the same time, most significantly and most damning, we began to think of ourselves as separate from and superior to all the other Life of Earth.
“Anthropologists have assumed that organized religion began as a way of salving the tensions that inevitably arose when hunter-gatherers settled down, became farmers, and developed large societies.
Gobekli Tepe, to Schmidt’s way of thinking, suggests a reversal of that scenario: The construction of a massive temple by a group of foragers is evidence that organized religion could have come before the rise of agriculture and other aspects of civilization. It suggests that the human impulse to gather for sacred rituals arose as humans shifted from seeing themselves as part of the natural world to seeking mastery over it” (emphasis added). (source)
The way things are going, I think “to see the future“, at least near term is getting to be not much harder than “seeing” the distant past.
Just my opinion
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Industrial Civilization – A Cult of Death.
LikeLike