Introduction
In recent years, the United States has witnessed a perilous convergence of authoritarian ambition, executive lawlessness, and grandiose corruption emblematic of historical decadence. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the failed but dangerous attempts of Donald Trump to consolidate power—efforts that, far from being aberrations, intimately reflect the late-stage crises of industrial civilization: declining returns on energy, increasing inequality, corroded institutions, and the desperate preservation of privilege atop a hollowing society. This essay investigates the mechanisms and risks of Trump’s regime—from his empowerment of ICE as a personal militia and deregulation-fueled corruption to the historic decadence that portends collapse—and situates these trends against the background of civilizational decline.
Authoritarian Strategies and the Theater of Power
The Politics of Deliberate Decadence
Trump’s manner of rule derives directly from a long tradition of strongman politics, in which spectacle is a central tool of domination. The “deliberate decadence” of golden ballrooms, extravagant parties, and social media performances is not merely bad taste, but an assertion of power: “To flaunt what others cannot have or should not approve is to remind them who rules and who obeys”. Across history—from Louis XIV’s Versailles to Nero’s opulent banquets—the dramatization of luxury has served as both intimidation and humiliation, a calculated demonstration that the ruler exists “above your suffering” and is immune to consequence.
This corrosion of restraint and reason is closely tied to the weakening of the rule of law. The overt displays of wealth and impunity signal to followers the regime’s invulnerability, even as they erode trust in institutions and foster cynicism. In Trump’s presidency and post-presidency, such decadence has become a language of power meant to silence criticism, reinforce the mythos of the leader, and marginalize those who dissent.
ICE and the Personal Police Force
Perhaps the most alarming manifestation of Trump’s authoritarian ambition is the transformation of ICE into what critics have termed a quasi-personal police force. Federal, militarized, and increasingly unaccountable, ICE’s expanded powers have facilitated forced disappearances, aggressive raids, and violations of civil rights—often targeting marginalized groups and political opponents.
Gavin Newsom describes this force as “the largest private domestic army of its type, police force anywhere in the world,” with tens of thousands “swearing an oath of office to him, not the Constitution of the United States”. This marks a critical departure from democratic oversight: ICE’s loyalty is redirected toward the executive, not constitutional principles. Mass deployments of ICE, Border Patrol, the National Guard, and even active-duty Marines to American cities for domestic policing duties underscore the normalization of executive militarization and the erosion of civilian checks.
Suppressing Democracy: Elections and Dissent
Trump’s authoritarian “playbook” extends to direct manipulation of the electoral system: redistricting, disenfranchisement, intimidation at polling stations via law enforcement, and disinformation campaigns. By seizing control of local and state-level power and threatening dissenters with law enforcement toolkits, the regime undermines the democratic process itself.
Corruption, Deregulation, and Financial Decay
Echoes of the 1920s: Corruption as Collapse
The spectacle of decadence is inseparable from systemic corruption and deregulation. Trump’s regime has presided over a dramatic dismantling of market guardrails—firing regulators, cutting SEC staff, suspending oversight, and enabling risky financial schemes. The result is an “overheated economy on the brink of demise,” where speculative investment, fraud, and “Ponzi-like” bubbles proliferate unchecked.
Author William A. Birdthistle, former SEC director, observes alarming parallels: “Published a century ago, F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby captured the culture of an overheated economy on the brink of demise. Just as Jay Gatsby fell from the height of fortune to an ignominious death, the 1920s roared with financial overindulgence until the markets drowned in the Wall Street crash of 1929. The Great Depression followed, and the consequences for the global economy proved calamitous”.
The same economic recklessness is evident today: soaring unregulated markets, consumer debt reminiscent of 1920s installment plans, and the rise of “crypto” as a new locus of predatory speculation. In this environment, the administration actively encourages opacity, even proposing to let private equity schemes access everyday retirement funds—a plan Birdthistle calls “as compelling as a plan to democratize brain surgery”. As protections recede, “fraudsters flourish.” The administration “is stamping on the gas while turning off the headlights”.
Lawlessness as Governance
The removal of regulatory “chaperones” is masked by a rhetoric of “law and order”—pseudo-moralistic justifications for real, systemic lawlessness. Trump deploys troops and ICE “to confront American citizens in our own cities, while it removes the constables patrolling our financial markets”. The contradiction is instructive: public spectacle, militarized policing, and punitive measures for dissent coexist with an elite free-for-all behind the scenes. In sum, corruption and decadence are not simply effects of late-stage capitalism; they are also deliberate strategies for consolidating control and diverting accountability.
Industrial Civilization in Decline
Declining Energy Returns and Societal Fragility
The late industrial era is fraught with material limits, chief among them the declining global energy return on investment (EROI). Once, fossil fuels delivered unprecedented leverage: enormous social, economic, and technical surpluses enabled dramatic expansions of infrastructure, education, and standard of living. As high-grade energy sources dwindle, their replacement by renewables proves, so far, less efficient and unable to sustain the legacy systems built in the age of surplus.
Today’s industrial systems are “struggling to provide for basic needs or adapt to disruptive technologies” at the very moment that progress is most critical. The mass infrastructure of civilization (roads, power plants, food distribution, water systems) faces compounding risks from underinvestment, political gridlock, and worsening climate impacts.
Authoritarianism as Defensive Reaction
In this context, authoritarian regimes arise not as progressive visionaries, but as defenders of the status quo: “authoritarian leaders act to preserve their own power and the existing order at precisely the moment that radical change and renewal are needed”. By intensifying suppression, policing dissent, and privileging the old industries, authoritarians protect a system in terminal decline, exacerbating fragility rather than enabling renewal.
Empires and Collapse: Case Studies
Historians note that, across civilizations, the same pattern recurs. A consistent sequence is charted: political corruption, violence against marginalized groups, anti-intellectualism, increasingly ostentatious displays by the wealthy, and infrastructural decay as governments neglect or cannot maintain basic systems. It is, in essence, a textbook of what is occurring with Trump’s America: lavish, isolating parties for the elite; dereliction for everyone else; resentment weaponized against minorities and dissidents; collapse of public goods; and, eventually, internal strife and breakdown.
The Dismantling of Public Health Under RFK Jr.
Trump’s appointment of RFK Jr. as Secretary of Health and Human Services precipitated an immediate, sweeping assault on the nation’s foundational health institutions. Kennedy moved quickly to lay off and push out experts across agencies, shut down regional offices, and slash more than $11 billion in federal funding crucial for laboratory upgrades, epidemiological tracking, infectious disease monitoring, and emergency response. These abrupt and “haphazard” actions have left state and local agencies reeling, their ability to contain outbreaks of measles, influenza, or more novel threats critically compromised.
As the CDC hemorrhaged talent and leadership, Kennedy justified purges by attacking the agency as “the most corrupt health agency, and perhaps the most corrupt agency in the entire federal government,” further fueling public distrust. He canceled vaccine clinics, suspended critical advisory meetings, and silenced scientific input with secretive, politically motivated reviews—all while advancing vaccine skepticism and reckless health misinformation that undermined immunization campaigns and fostered renewed disease outbreaks.
These developments cemented America’s loss of global leadership in public health innovation and pandemic preparedness, leading experts to warn that Kennedy’s regime is “dismantling the federal public health infrastructure” in ways “dramatic and quick and so haphazard, it’s going to cost lives”. Essential teams fighting HIV, tuberculosis, domestic violence, childhood lead poisoning, and occupational health were fired en masse. The resulting void in research, emergency response, and disease surveillance leaves the entire country more susceptible not only to epidemics, but to the cascading economic and social impacts of unmanaged health crises—directly undermining the resilience of industrial civilization at a critical historical inflection point.
ICE: Militarization and Internal Colonialism
The Expansion of ICE
Trump’s use of ICE, Border Patrol, and active-duty military as domestic police is a radical escalation. Newsom’s account of California’s recent experience links the proliferation of such agencies directly to the ambition of personal rule: “He sent out ICE and Border Patrol to intimidate folks from walking in to our event. He ended up arresting this poor soul that was just trying to sell strawberries as collateral damage to intimidate us. That is a preview, Stephen [Colbert], of things to come in voting booths and polling places across this country. He federalized 4,000 National Guard in my state. He still has hundreds of federalized National Guard. He sent the United States Marines, not overseas, but to an American city”.
Loyalty to the Executive, Not the Law
Most alarming, ICE operatives and other federal law enforcement increasingly “appear to be swearing an oath of office to him [Trump], not the Constitution of the United States.” This resembles the Praetorian Guards or secret police of previous authoritarian regimes—state actors who enforce the will of the leader and see constitutional or moral constraints as irrelevant or subversive. The sheer scale—“30,000 people”—combined with secrecy and immunity, means ICE has become an agent of terror, wielded against civilian populations for political gain.
Decadence as Collapse
The Performance of Power
Every performance of grandeur—the “triumphal arches,” “boat parades,” and “sequined courtiers”—is not just spectacle, but a warning sign. History remembers Marie Antoinette (“Let them eat cake”) not because the attribution was accurate, but because the phrase “captures the logic of ruling decadence. Her luxury wasn’t just obliviousness—it was an assertion: I live above your suffering”. Each ritual, each show of gold and opulence, is “meant to humiliate restraint, reason, and law.”
However, history also shows that such displays are fraught with fear. Beneath the performance is “the fear of being seen as he is, of being small, of losing the stage”—a warning of fragility. As the man behind the curtain is revealed, the collapse of the “theater of power” becomes swift and catastrophic.
Self-Destruction and “Extinction Burst”
The Terminal Panic of Authoritarian Regimes
The internal logic of failing authoritarian regimes is one of escalating desperation. As legitimacy slips—confirmed by electoral repudiation—Trump’s ideological faction undergoes an “extinction burst”: an explosive period of hyper-aggressive reassertion designed to cement gains before the collapse becomes terminal.
Steve Bannon, Trump adviser, openly admitted: “If we lose the midterms and we lose 2028, some in this room are going to prison, myself included.” This is not bravado, but fear. The movement’s control is slipping, and its actions grow more extreme and error-prone. As this faction “pushes too hard, too fast, everyone will lash out… the more aggressive they get, the more they rush… the more mistakes they’re gonna make, the more lines they’re going to cross. They push too hard, too fast, everyone will lash out”. This dynamic is visible across history: the more authoritarian regimes squeeze, the faster collapse arrives.
Collapse of Industrial Civilization: The Macro Context
Structural Barriers to Renewal
The late industrial world confronts limits that no amount of executive performance, repression, or technological optimism can overcome. One of the most fundamental constraints is the declining Energy Return on Investment (EROI)—the ratio of usable energy generated to energy expended in extraction, production, and delivery. Over the past century, the EROI for oil extraction has plunged from values over 1000:1 in the early twentieth century to below 10:1 today for many conventional resources, and often as low as 5:1 in more recent U.S. fields. A 2024 Nature study confirms that the “useful-stage EROI” for fossil fuel sources is now just 3.5:1 on average, with coal performing somewhat better, but oil and gas in clear decline.
While renewable energy technologies such as solar and wind offer EROIs that sometimes reach 10:1 to 20:1 under optimal conditions, recent peer-reviewed research emphasizes that large-scale deployment and associated battery storage, grid upgrades, and intermittent supply smoothing drive those EROI values lower in real-world system-wide contexts. According to Nature (2024), ambitious transitions to renewables may temporarily boost system-wide EROI, but will eventually drive it downward as society grapples with the massive energy inputs required for infrastructure expansion and maintenance. In many plausible future scenarios, global EROI falls below the threshold—often cited as 7:1—needed to sustain economic growth and the complexity of modern civilization.
This erosion of net energy surplus means that the material basis underpinning social complexity, infrastructure maintenance, and economic dynamism is shrinking. The fossil-fueled expansion that built suburban America, highways, and global trade since World War II was underwritten by “golden era” EROIs of 30:1 or higher. Today, this advantage is over: the energy economy now faces an “energy trap”—legacy infrastructure can’t be replaced or maintained at scale, but transitioning to renewables is itself energy intensive, slow, and systemically disruptive.
These limits are not simply technical barriers; they impose structural constraints on every aspect of policy ambition and societal renewal. As authoritarian regimes scramble to defend the status quo, protect fossil interests, and suppress dissent, they are not solving the underlying problem but merely postponing inevitable collapse. Thus, declining EROI is a robust, empirically confirmed driver behind the faltering structures of advanced civilization—a trend that starkly exposes the hollowness of contemporary spectacle, rhetoric, and autocratic control.
The Central Irony: Power and Powerlessness
As the gap between spectacle and reality grows, and infrastructure falters, societies marked by authoritarian excess increasingly turn to performative displays of strength—rallies, parades, shows of wealth, and harsh enforcement—to mask their foundational weaknesses. Yet decadence becomes self-critique: these grandiose displays serve only to underline the system’s exhaustion and fragility, offering spectacle as a substitute for real achievement.
The more leaders invest in illusion and domination, the more they highlight their impotence to address genuine crises—whether infrastructural, social, or economic. Spectacle blurs the boundary between power and impotence; appearances take precedence over substance, masking social alienation while provoking resentment and rage beneath the facade. As rulers become ever more detached from the true condition of their society, their overt excesses and insistence on control expose their fear of dissent and decline. This paradox—where the assertion of total power reveals profound vulnerability—ensures that such displays ultimately hasten collapse, as the managed image of strength unravels under the weight of unmet needs and rising anger.
Conclusion: When the Performance Ends
Trump’s failed authoritarian project, with its ICE enforcers, deregulation, and “let them eat cake” pageantry, is not only a threat to democracy—it is proof of how industrial civilization, facing terminal decline, can tip into violence, spectacle, and self-destruction. The performance, ultimately, ends “when the people stop believing the show”. Collapse comes not as the abrupt end of the spectacle, but as a slow-motion unraveling of legitimacy, institutions, and the capacity to maintain society for all, not just the few.
The road ahead is fraught. Authoritarianism will not resurrect the age of fossil plenty, nor will the militarization of everyday life rebuild corroded institutions. Only radical reform, civic renewal, and the courage to face limits—material, social, and ethical—can avert the terminal trajectory of decadent decline. The clock, as history warns, is ticking.
References:
-
Aramendia, Emmanuel, Paul E. Brockway, Peter G. Taylor, Jonathan B. Norman, Matthew K. Heun, and Zeke Marshall. “Estimation of Useful-Stage Energy Returns on Investment for Fossil Fuels and Implications for Renewable Energy Systems.” Nature Energy 9 (2024): 803–816. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01518-6.
-
Birdthistle, William A. “Trump Is Pushing Us Toward a Crash. It Could Be 1929 All Over Again.” New York Times, November 7, 2025. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/07/opinion/donald-trump-great-gatsby-roating-20s-sec.html
-
Cash, Steven A. “The Theater of Power: Trump and the Tradition of Deliberate Decadence.” Steady State, November 3, 2025. https://steadystate1.substack.com/p/the-theater-of-power-trump-and-the
-
“Border Patrol Agents Replace Top Leadership at ICE.” ACLU, November 5, 2025. https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/border-patrol-agents-replace-top-leadership-at-ice-offices-despite-human-rights-violations
-
“FACT SHEET: Trump, Musk, & RFK Jr. Hollow Out HHS, Threatening Americans’ Health and Wellbeing.” U.S. Senate, Patty Murray, April 1, 2025. https://www.appropriations.senate.gov/news/minority/fact-sheet-trump-musk-and-rfk-jr-hollow-out-hhs-threatening-americans-health-and-wellbeing
-
Fadelli, Ingrid. “Transitioning to Renewable Energy Systems Might Not Entail a Decline in Net Energy.” Tech Xplore, June 15, 2024. https://techxplore.com/news/2024-06-transitioning-renewable-energy-entail-decline.html.
-
“Fossil Fuels Offer a Poor Return on Energy Investment.” Environment News, University of Leeds, July 11, 2019. https://www.leeds.ac.uk/news-environment/news/article/4444/fossil-fuels-offer-a-poor-return-on-energy-investment.
-
“Frank Vogl on why Trump’s financial deregulation is likely to lead to another global economic crash” Keen On, February 16, 2025. https://keenon.substack.com/p/episode-2239-frank-vogl-on-why-trumps
-
Harper, Tyler Austin. “The 100-Year Extinction Panic Is Back, Right on Schedule.” New York Times, January 25, 2024. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/26/opinion/polycrisis-doom-extinction-humanity.html
-
“How RFK Jr. Dismantled Trust in Public Health: A Student’s Warning for the Future.” Union of Concerned Scientists, August 28, 2025. https://blog.ucsusa.org/public-health/how-rfk-jr-dismantled-trust-in-public-health/
-
“How RFK Jr. is Upending Public Health.” Tradeoffs, April 10, 2025. https://tradeoffs.org/2025/04/10/how-rfk-jr-upending-public-health/
-
“How Trump is Building a Violent, Shadowy Federal Police Force.” ProPublica, October 18, 2025. https://www.propublica.org/article/trump-dhs-ice-secret-police-civil-rights-unaccountable
-
“ICE is Using Aggressive Tactics to Bolster Arrests, Experts Say.” CNN, October 16, 2025. https://www.cnn.com/2025/10/16/us/ice-tactics-raids-arrests-dhs
-
“Human Civilization at a Critical Junction Between Authoritarian and Sustainable Pathways.” YubaNet, December 16, 2024. https://yubanet.com/scitech/human-civilization-at-a-critical-junction-between-authoritarian-collapse-and-superabundance/
-
“Misra, Siddharth. Plummeting ‘Energy Return on Investment’ of Oil and the Impact on Global Energy Landscape.” Journal of Petroleum Technology, March 20, 2023. https://jpt.spe.org/plummeting-energy-return-on-investment-of-oil-and-the-impact-on-global-energy-landscape
-
“RFK Jr slings accusations and defends public-health upheaval at fiery hearing.” Nature, September 5, 2025. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-02845-8
-
“RFK Jr. Is Systematically Undermining Vaccine Science and Public Health.” Center for American Progress, June 27, 2025. https://www.americanprogress.org/article/rfk-jr-is-systematically-undermining-vaccine-science-and-endangering-health/
-
“Sahin, Hasret, A. A. Solomon, Arman Aghahosseini, and Christian Breyer. Systemwide Energy Return on Investment in a Sustainable Transition towards Net Zero Power Systems.” Nature Communications 15, no. 208 (2024). https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-44232-9
-
“Solomon, A. A., Hasret Sahin, and Christian Breyer. The Pitfall in Designing Future Electrical Power Systems Without Considering Energy Return on Investment in Planning.” Applied Energy 369 (2024): 123570. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2024.123570. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192400953X
-
“STATEMENT RELEASE: Doctors for America Calls for the Resignation or Removal of HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.” Doctors for America, April 15, 2025. https://doctorsforamerica.org/statement-release-rfk-resignation/
-
“The Authoritarian Playbook for 2025.” authoritarianplaybook2025.org, January 2024. https://authoritarianplaybook2025.org/
-
“The Real-Time Demise of American Democracy Under Trump.” Common Dreams, October 6, 2025. https://www.commondreams.org/opinion/demise-us-democracy-trump
-
“Trump is Abusing His Power to Build a Dangerous, National Policing Apparatus.” ACLU, October 3, 2025. https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/trump-is-abusing-his-power-to-build-a-dangerous-national-policing-force
-
“US: ICE Abuses in Los Angeles Set Stage for Other Cities.” Human Rights Watch, August 15, 2025. https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/11/04/us-ice-abuses-in-los-angeles-set-stage-for-other-cities
-
“U.S. is sliding toward authoritarianism, hundreds of scholars say.” NPR, April 22, 2025. https://www.npr.org/2025/04/22/nx-s1-5340753/trump-democracy-authoritarianism-competive-survey-political-scientist
-
“Where Trump’s Redistricting Battle Stands Now.” Democracy Docket, November 2, 2025. https://www.democracydocket.com/news/where-trumps-redistricting-battle-stands-now/
-
“Will Authoritarianism Derail the Shift to a Postmaterialist Civilisation?” Earth4All, December 16, 2024. https://earth4all.life/will-authoritarianism-derail-the-shift-to-a-postmaterialist-civilisation/
Collapse of Industrial Civilization 